A buy-and-sell agreement is simply a contract between two or more people, most commonly used between partners, shareholders, or members of the same business entity. However, unrelated parties can also agree to buy a person’s shares in a company. This is often called a one‑sided buy‑and‑sell or a unilateral contract. For simplicity, I’ll refer to all of these contracts collectively as buy‑and‑sell agreements, because the terminology is not the point I’m contesting.
In these agreements, the parties decide that when a specific event occurs—usually death or disability—one party will buy and the other will sell their shares in a business. As far as I’m aware, no law restricts who may enter into such an agreement. The usual limits apply: contracts involving crime or those that go against public policy are invalid. For example, you cannot contract to kill someone, or require a person to divorce their spouse as a condition for performance. Beyond these boundaries, parties are generally free to contract as they choose. As long as there is consensus, capacity, lawfulness, possible performance, and compliance with any required formalities, we have a valid legal contract.
Let’s use a simple example:
- Mr A owns 100% of company ABC.
- ABC has an employee who is critical to the business and would like to own the company when Mr A dies.
- Mr A and the employee agree that, on Mr A’s death, the employee will buy Mr A’s shares.
Is there anything that stops them from entering into a buy‑and‑sell agreement? I believe not.
This is where the financial planner plays a role. The employee will need cash to buy the shares when Mr A dies, so a life insurance policy is recommended to fund the agreement. And this is where the confusion starts. I often read the following claims:
- “The employee is not a shareholder, so they cannot be party to a buy/sell agreement.”
- “The agreement is only lawful if Mr A first sells at least 1% of his shares to the employee.”
- “Only once the employee is a shareholder can they enter into a valid buy/sell agreement.”
I’m not sure where this supposed “illegality” comes from. My suspicion is that we’re confusing the requirements of the Estate Duty Act with the requirements for a buy/sell agreement.
The Estate Duty Act provides, in summary, that a life policy used to fund a buy‑and‑sell arrangement can be exempt from estate duty if, at the date of death, the parties are co‑owners (for example, shareholders in the same company). That requirement applies to the tax exemption on the policy, not to the validity of the agreement itself.
So, in our example:
- The buy/sell agreement between Mr A and the employee is valid and lawful.
- The life policy used to fund it may not qualify for the estate duty exemption because they are not co‑shareholders at death.
- That simply means the policy proceeds may attract estate duty. It does not make the agreement unlawful.
If estate duty is a concern, you can adjust the policy amount to cover the duty. What you cannot do is create artificial structures just to “force” the policy into an exemption.
This brings us to the “sell 1% first” advice.
Recommending that Mr A sells a token 1% shareholding to the employee purely to tick the “co‑owner” box is not only incorrect—it can be harmful.
SARS looks at transactions on a substance‑over‑form basis. If that 1% stake has no genuine commercial purpose and exists only to secure an estate duty exemption, SARS may ignore it. In that case:
- The exemption may fail.
- The policy proceeds may still be treated as “deemed property” in Mr A’s estate.
- Liquidity planning may be compromised because the estate duty impact was not properly considered.
The law requires that the purpose of the policy and the agreement is to enable surviving co‑owners to acquire the deceased’s interest. The exemption hinges on that genuine intention—not on arbitrary percentages of shareholding.
So, myth number 1: You must first sell 1% of the shares to the future buyer for the buy‑and‑sell agreement to be lawful.
In my view, that’s incorrect. The agreement can be perfectly valid between Mr A and the employee, even if the employee is not yet a shareholder. The estate duty exemption on the policy is a separate question—and trying to “game” that exemption with artificial share transfers can create more problems than it solves.
I’d be very interested to hear from those who see this differently, especially if you can point to the specific legal authority behind the “1% first” requirement.